Malta’s gaming sector, across both online and land-based gaming, operates within a highly connected ecosystem. Gaming entities rely on third-party providers for platforms, technology, game design, payments, data processing and other services that support their day-to-day operations.
The Malta Gaming Authority (MGA) has recognised this interdependence. Its outsourcing policy acknowledges the gaming industry’s increasing reliance on business-to-business service providers across the supply chain.
However, direct suppliers often have dependencies of their own. For instance, a platform provider may rely on another company for infrastructure or a specialised service. That provider then becomes part of the wider delivery chain supporting the gaming entity.
This is where fourth-party risk comes into the picture. It is the risk arising from organisations that a company’s direct suppliers themselves depend upon.
This deserves attention because a gaming entity can have a strong relationship with its direct supplier and still be exposed to a provider with which it has no direct contractual relationship. If that underlying provider suffers a significant disruption, the effects may travel through the supply chain and ultimately reach the gaming entity.
Third-party risk management primarily focuses on the direct relationship between an entity and its supplier. Due diligence, contractual protections, performance monitoring and periodic reviews all play an important role.
However, these measures may not provide the full picture.
Consider a gaming entity engaging an external provider for a critical service. Management may have thoroughly assessed and evaluated that provider, but the provider itself may rely heavily on another organisation for an important part of the service.
This demonstrates that operational dependency can extend beyond contractual accountability. It requires organisations to look beyond the immediate supplier and consider the wider network supporting the service.
The issue is not that suppliers use subcontractors. Within the gaming industry, interconnected services are a normal part of the business environment.
The real issue is visibility.
Management may have detailed information about a critical supplier but limited knowledge of the organisations supporting that supplier.
This raises practical questions such as:
The answers to these questions can reveal risks that may not be apparent from a standard supplier register.
One important area to consider is concentration risk.
Consider a gaming entity working with three independent technology suppliers. All three have passed the organisation’s supplier assessment and evaluation. Looking at each relationship individually, management may reasonably believe that the risk is diversified.
But what if all three suppliers depend on the same underlying infrastructure provider?
On paper, the entity has several independent suppliers. In practice, they may all depend on the same provider, creating a concentration risk that is not immediately visible.
For critical services, looking beyond the supplier list can therefore give management a more complete understanding of the entity’s actual risk exposure.
Responsibility for managing fourth-party risk ultimately sits with management and those charged with governance.
Auditors can question, challenge and provide assurance within the scope of their work, but they do not own the underlying business risk.
The MGA’s outsourcing policy requires authorised persons to assign an employee with overall responsibility for an outsourced service who has sufficient knowledge and experience to challenge the performance of the third-party provider.
The policy also reinforces an important principle: outsourcing a service does not outsource responsibility for it.
Management should therefore consider a straightforward question:
Do we understand who our critical suppliers depend on well enough to manage the risk?
Where internal audit adds value
Where an internal audit function exists, it can provide an important independent perspective.
Internal audit does not need to assess every company used by every supplier. A risk-based approach can instead focus on the services and dependencies that are most material to the organisation.
Internal audit can consider whether management has identified critical outsourced services, understood the key dependencies behind them, assessed concentration risk and established appropriate monitoring arrangements.
However, not every gaming entity has an internal audit function.
The absence of internal audit does not mean the organisation should be left without appropriate challenge or assurance. Management and those charged with governance should consider how assurance over important dependencies is obtained through the organisation’s existing governance, risk, compliance and monitoring arrangements, and whether additional independent assurance may be appropriate.
External audit is not a replacement for management oversight.
An external auditor would not ordinarily be expected to examine every supplier or every fourth party within the supply chain. The auditor’s work is shaped by the nature and scope of the engagement.
Fourth-party risk becomes relevant where an underlying dependency affects a risk, process or control that is relevant to that engagement.
The MGA Compliance Audit Manual provides a useful underlying principle by requiring auditors to apply professional judgement based on the facts and circumstances of the individual licensee, maintain professional scepticism and develop appropriate procedures in response to identified risks.
The objective is therefore not to investigate every dependency, but to follow relevant risks sufficiently to understand whether they matter to the engagement.
Fourth-party risk does not necessarily require another complicated framework. The starting point should be to focus on what matters most.
Identify the services whose disruption would have a significant impact on the business.
Determine whether critical suppliers rely on other providers to deliver important elements of their service.
Consider whether apparently independent suppliers depend on the same underlying organisations or infrastructure.
Ensure that someone within the organisation has clear responsibility for overseeing each critical supplier relationship.
Ask what the organisation would do if a critical supplier, or an important provider behind that supplier, became unavailable.
Where internal audit exists, use it as an independent source of challenge. Where it does not, consider how management and those charged with governance can obtain appropriate assurance over significant dependencies.
Malta’s gaming industry benefits considerably from technology, specialisation and a strong network of service providers. However, those advantages also create dependencies that may not always be visible through the direct contractual relationship.
That is why fourth-party risk deserves attention.
Ultimately, it is about understanding what the business depends upon, identifying where those dependencies are concentrated and considering what could happen if an important part of the chain fails.
Management and those charged with governance remain responsible for managing the risk. Internal audit, where present, can independently challenge how that risk is being managed, while external audit can provide another perspective where those risks are relevant to the scope of the engagement.
RSM Malta supports organisations in assessing third- and fourth-party dependencies, strengthening outsourcing governance and considering whether existing risk management and assurance arrangements provide appropriate visibility over critical suppliers.
To discuss how your organisation can strengthen its approach to supplier and fourth-party risk, contact RSM Malta’s Governance, Risk and Compliance team.
...
...